Tim Latimer

November 10, 2026

The 7 Types of IDC Candidates You’ll Meet on Every Course

GoPro, IDC, PADI, Scuba Diving | 0 comments

An IDC brings together people with different backgrounds, personalities, strengths and weaknesses. Some candidates start confidently and need to learn patience. Others arrive unsure of themselves and discover that they're much better teachers than they ever imagined.

Scuba divers going to shore in Dauin

Every PADI Instructor Development Course (IDC) is different. The candidates change, the conditions change, and no two courses ever seem to run exactly the same way.

But after teaching IDCs for a while, you start to notice certain patterns.

You meet the candidate who has prepared so thoroughly that they could probably teach the entire course themselves. Then there's the one who seems completely relaxed until you ask them to stand up and give a five-minute teaching presentation. There's always someone who wants to know their score before they've even finished the assessment.

And somewhere in the group, there's usually a candidate who looks like they've got everything figured out, right up until they discover that teaching scuba is a little more complicated than being good at diving.

Of course, these aren't official categories. Nobody arrives at an IDC with a label stuck to their forehead.
But after years of training Divemasters and developing scuba instructors, I've come to recognize a few familiar personalities.
Here are seven of them. See if you recognize yourself!

Course Director in Dauin PADI IDC

1. The Overachiever

The candidate who has prepared for absolutely everything.

This person arrives with immaculate notes, color-coded folders, carefully organized presentations and enough study material to sink a small boat.

They know the standards. They know the theory. They've probably watched every video available and spent half the night rehearsing their first teaching presentation.

You can't fault their dedication. Preparation is important, and this candidate has certainly done their homework.

The problem comes when preparation turns into overthinking.

They can spend so much time trying to get everything perfect that they forget the actual goal: teaching someone else.

Their presentations become rehearsed speeches. They worry about remembering every word instead of paying attention to the people in front of them. If somebody asks an unexpected question, they can lose their place because it wasn't part of the script.

The lesson: Preparation should give you confidence, not become a cage. Learn the material, understand what you're teaching and then allow yourself to be a human being.

I remember one candidate, who will remain unnamed, earning the nickname "Professor" for their knowledge development presentations. What should have been an explanation of a diving concept turned into something resembling a university dissertation.

I always say that a classroom presentation should be about as long as your favourite punk rock song, not American Pie or November Rain.

You need to get the important information across, make sure your students understand it and keep them engaged. You're not trying to record an audiobook.

Sometimes, less really is more.

2. The Know-It-All

The experienced Divemaster who has seen everything. Or so they think.

This candidate has thousands of dives, years of experience and plenty of stories. They've worked with difficult customers, dived in challenging conditions and probably have strong opinions about how things should be done.

And to be fair, that experience is valuable.

But sometimes the candidate struggles to accept that being an experienced diver and becoming an effective scuba instructor are two different things.

They've been doing certain things a particular way for years. When you suggest a different approach, their first instinct is to explain why their way works perfectly well.

And it probably does, in the circumstances they're used to.

But an IDC is about learning to teach within the training system, meet the required standards and adapt your approach to students who may have very little experience.

The lesson: Experience is an advantage, but only if you're willing to keep learning. The IDC isn't asking you to forget everything you know. It's asking you to build on it.

Teaching in the Philippines, I often see this with local Divemasters who have an incredible depth of practical experience. They've spent years in the water, working with divers and dealing with situations that you simply can't learn about from a textbook.

That experience is a huge asset. But translating it into effective teaching sometimes requires a change of mindset.

As the old saying goes, "You can't teach an old dog new tricks."

Fortunately, there's another saying, this one from Star Trek: "You will be assimilated."

And that's pretty much how it works. We keep working on it, introduce new approaches and explain why the standards matter. Eventually, even the most stubborn old dogs start to see the benefits.

The trick isn't to throw away your experience. It's to recognize that there's always something new to learn.

PADI instructor student having fun un Dauin

3. The Score Chaser

The candidate who wants to know their grade before they've processed the feedback.

You finish an assessment, and before you've even had a chance to explain what went well and what needs improvement, the question comes.

"What score did I get?"

This candidate knows the evaluation criteria inside out. They understand how assessments work and are determined to achieve the highest possible marks.

There's nothing inherently wrong with that. Standards matter, and wanting to do well is perfectly reasonable.

But the Score Chaser can become so focused on the number that they miss the lesson.

A presentation that earns a strong score isn't necessarily the end of the learning process. Equally, a disappointing result doesn't mean someone is going to be a poor instructor.

What matters is understanding why you received that feedback and what you're going to do differently next time.

The lesson: Use scores to measure progress, not define your worth. The real goal is becoming a capable instructor, not collecting perfect marks.

I once had a candidate who was so obsessed with their scores that they argued over every point they lost.

Eventually, during an optional presentation, I decided to turn the tables on them.

Their presentation had some obvious mistakes, and several things went wrong. During the debrief, instead of highlighting those issues, I told them they'd earned a perfect five out of five.

I can still remember watching the internal debate playing out across their face.

They knew it wasn't a five. They knew exactly what had gone wrong. But now they had to decide whether to argue with me when I'd just given them the perfect score they'd been chasing.

Eventually, I pulled them aside, and we had a conversation about the difference between achieving a perfect score and actually learning something.

The point wasn't to trick them. It was to help them recognize that the feedback they received was far more valuable than the number attached to it.

There's nothing wrong with wanting to score well. Just don't become so focused on the score that you forget why you're there in the first place.

PADI IDC learning sessions

4. The Nervous Wreck

The candidate who is convinced they're going to fail.

This one is particularly interesting because nervousness can disguise a lot of potential.

They might be excellent divers. They might understand the theory perfectly. They might even have plenty of experience working with students.

But put them in front of a group for a teaching presentation, and suddenly they forget how to form a sentence. Sometimes, they even start making mistakes with skills they've performed perfectly well a hundred times before.

They speak too quickly, overthink every question and spend far more time worrying about what everyone thinks of them than concentrating on the people they're teaching.

The interesting thing is that these candidates can sometimes make remarkable progress once they realize that nobody expects them to be perfect on day one.

The IDC is where you're supposed to practise, make mistakes, receive feedback and improve. That's the whole point of the process.

The lesson: Confidence doesn't have to come before competence. Sometimes, confidence is the result of practising, learning and discovering that you can do things you previously thought were beyond you.

As a Course Director, my job is to help candidates develop the skills and meet the requirements needed to become entry-level scuba instructors. I'm not expecting anyone to finish the IDC and Instructor Examination as a fully polished, experienced instructor.

That comes with time and experience.

In fact, you never really stop learning or perfecting the art of teaching. Every class brings different students, different challenges and new opportunities to improve.

Your confidence grows as you start teaching, recognize that you're getting better and learn to trust your own abilities.

I've seen nervous candidates finish an IDC with a completely different outlook from the one they arrived with. They haven't suddenly become experts at everything. They've simply realized that they can do this.

Sometimes, that's the biggest breakthrough of all.

5. The Natural

The candidate who makes everything look ridiculously easy.

Their first presentation is clear, relaxed and engaging. Their demonstrations are excellent. They seem comfortable in front of a group, and feedback appears to make an immediate difference.

Everyone else is quietly wondering what they're doing wrong.

But here's the catch: sometimes the Natural hasn't developed the habits that will help them improve further.

Because things come easily, they might not prepare as thoroughly as they should. They may struggle when they encounter a student who doesn't understand something immediately. Or they may assume that because their own performance is good, their teaching must be equally effective.

It doesn't always work that way.

Being a natural communicator is a great starting point, but teaching also requires patience, preparation and the ability to adapt.

The lesson: Talent helps, but don't confuse an easy start with having nothing left to learn.

Some candidates have been diving for so long, or started at such a young age, that they've forgotten how difficult certain skills can be for a beginner.

I've had candidates who genuinely struggled to understand why a student couldn't perform a skill that seemed completely straightforward to them.

"Just do it!" is a great slogan for running shoes, but it's not a particularly useful problem-solving technique when you're an instructor trying to help a struggling student.

Your job isn't to demonstrate how easy something is for you. It's to figure out why someone else is having difficulty and help them overcome it.

That might mean explaining the skill differently, breaking it into smaller steps, giving the student more time or simply helping them relax.

Being naturally good at diving is a great advantage. Learning to understand people who aren't naturally good at it is what makes you a better instructor.

Instructor Examination in Dauin

6. The Quiet Assassin

The candidate who says very little but gets on with the work.

They're not necessarily the loudest person in the classroom. They don't dominate discussions or constantly announce how much they've studied.

They listen.

They watch the other candidates. They absorb the feedback. They make notes, think about what they've been told and quietly apply it to the next presentation.

Then, somewhere along the way, you notice that they're improving rapidly.

Their first presentation might have been fairly ordinary. Their second is better. By the time you get to the later assessments, they're delivering confident, effective lessons.

There's no dramatic transformation or big announcement. They simply keep learning.

The lesson: You don't have to be the most confident or outspoken person on the course. Listening carefully, reflecting and consistently applying feedback can be incredibly effective.

These are the candidates who sometimes catch us by surprise.

At first, you might wonder whether they're taking everything in. They don't say much during discussions, and they're not always the first to volunteer an answer.

Then, seemingly out of nowhere, they put together a teaching presentation that incorporates all the organization, standards, setup and control we've been talking about for the past week.

Sometimes it leaves us with our jaws on the floor.

You find yourself thinking, "Where did that come from?"

The answer, of course, is that they've been paying attention all along.

They've watched what works, listened to the feedback given to other candidates and quietly worked out how to apply it themselves.

It's a good reminder that not everyone learns in the same way. Some people need to talk things through, while others prefer to observe, think and then put everything into practice.

As a Course Director, you learn not to judge a candidate's potential by how much they talk.

Sometimes, the quiet ones are the ones you need to watch.

7. The Last-Minute Hero

The candidate who somehow makes it all come together.

This candidate can be difficult to figure out.

They seem to spend a lot of time worrying about presentations, revising their plans and questioning whether they've prepared enough. Sometimes, they appear to be making things more complicated than they need to be.

Then, when it matters, they pull everything together.

Perhaps they needed a little longer to understand the process. Perhaps they were struggling to connect the theory with the practical side of teaching. Or perhaps they simply needed to stop overthinking everything.

When the pieces finally fall into place, the improvement can be impressive.

The danger is assuming that last-minute success is a reliable strategy.

An IDC moves quickly, and leaving everything until the last moment creates unnecessary pressure. There is a big difference between needing time to develop and repeatedly relying on a deadline to get you moving.

The lesson: Progress isn't always linear, but consistent preparation gives you the best chance of success. Don't make the course harder than it needs to be.

You can usually spot this candidate during someone else's classroom presentation.

While one candidate is standing at the front trying to teach, there's another sitting in the audience furiously scribbling on a scrap of paper.

They're writing their own presentation at the last possible minute.

Quite often, they manage to pull it off. They get up, deliver the presentation and somehow make it work.

But there's a problem beyond the unnecessary stress they're putting themselves through.

They're also not being a particularly good teammate.

Giving a presentation to a group is challenging enough without looking out at a class full of people who aren't paying attention because they're all busy preparing their own lessons.

The IDC is a shared learning experience. You can learn an enormous amount from watching other candidates, and they deserve the same attention and support that you expect when it's your turn at the front.

Come prepared, give your fellow candidates your attention and use their presentations as another opportunity to learn.

You might even discover a few things that make your own teaching better.

And if you're the Last-Minute Hero, perhaps leave the scrap paper in your bag and give yourself a little more time next round.

Your future self will thank you.

Conclusion: Which Type of IDC Candidate Are You?

The funny thing about these seven personalities is that most IDC candidates aren't just one of them.

You might be an Overachiever when it comes to theory, a Nervous Wreck before your first presentation and a Score Chaser when the results come back. You might even be a Know-It-All in the classroom and a Quiet Assassin when it comes to receiving feedback.

And that's perfectly fine.

PADI IDC candidates discussing plan of action

An IDC brings together people with different backgrounds, personalities, strengths and weaknesses. Some candidates start confidently and need to learn patience. Others arrive unsure of themselves and discover that they're much better teachers than they ever imagined.

There's no single personality type that guarantees you'll become a great scuba instructor.

What matters is being willing to learn, accepting feedback, and recognizing that the IDC is an opportunity to develop the skills you need to teach others.

The best candidates aren't necessarily the ones who start the course with the most experience, the highest confidence, or the best presentation skills.

They're the ones who are willing to improve.

So, which one are you?

And more importantly, which one will you be by the end of your IDC?

Upcoming 2027 IDC Dates & Pricing

Dive Promo!

10% off

Get 10% off your accommodation and free Nitrox tanks with a minimum pre-paid package of 3 nights & 6 dives

*Direct Bookings Only
**Booking period August 15th - December 1st, 2026