Tim Latimer

June 19, 2026

9 Mistakes I See in Almost Every IDC Candidate

IDC, PADI

Every year, Divemasters step into the IDC full of excitement, ambition, and sometimes a little anxiety. Almost all of them make mistakes early in the course — not because they’re bad divers, but because teaching diving is a whole new skill. Recognizing these common mistakes early allows candidates to grow faster, gain confidence, and develop […]

Instructor Development Course

Every year, Divemasters step into the IDC full of excitement, ambition, and sometimes a little anxiety. Almost all of them make mistakes early in the course — not because they’re bad divers, but because teaching diving is a whole new skill. Recognizing these common mistakes early allows candidates to grow faster, gain confidence, and develop the skills that will make them effective instructors. Over the years, I’ve noticed patterns in what trips up candidates during the IDC. In this blog, I’m going to share the 9 most common mistakes I see — along with practical tips to avoid them.

Most divemasters have had that moment when a quick headcount leaves you wondering, “Where is my diver?” It’s very common when guiding dives, as you’re constantly trying to find the critters or something interesting. After all, that’s what you’re there for, right? But as instructors, we have to switch into a different mode. Yes, it’s important to show people cool stuff, but more importantly, we are in charge of keeping them safe and teaching them new skills.

This isn’t always ingrained in instructor candidates from the start. Most are still operating as divemasters or guides. This can lead them to turn their back on their class. When you do that, you can expect problems. By the end of the IDC, candidates usually correct this simple-to-fix mistake, but it’s a hard lesson in the moment — especially when the CD or Staff instructors send “students” away from the group when they aren’t being supervised correctly.

Mistake #1 – Trying to Teach Too Much

Many new instructors assume that more information equals better teaching. They cram every detail they know into presentations, which often overwhelms students. Effective teaching is about clarity, simplicity, and pacing. Focus on essential points and allow students to absorb one skill before moving to the next.

When teaching dive theory, there’s often a desire to flex our knowledge or cover absolutely everything. But just because you know decompression theory inside and out doesn’t mean your student needs all that. If you’re teaching a PADI Open Water student about decompression and start bringing up M-values, tissue compartments, and half times, you’re going to lose them. It’s interesting information, but save it for your divemaster candidate.

Some of that expanded information might stick with your student, but it might come at the expense of a more basic concept that’s more relevant at the time. Keep the information relevant to the level of certification you’re issuing. Entry-level divers are just that — “entry level.” Let them master the basics first, then expand when they’re ready. Your students will thank you. The ones who want more info will ask — trust me.

Mistake #2 – Forgetting That Students Are Nervous

This one is more for your first actual courses, but is important. It’s easy to get caught up in demonstrating perfect skills and forget that students might feel anxious. Empathy is as important as technical skill. Understanding how a student feels and adjusting your pace or explanation style can make all the difference in how quickly they learn.

Not everyone takes to diving like a fish to water. Some people are genuinely terrified. It’s easy to forget how difficult learning a new skill can be, especially when you are effortlessly comfortable with it yourself. As an instructor, you are in charge of the pace of learning. Sometimes that pace is rapid, other times glacially slow. Add in external pressures — pool time limits, boat schedules, management pushing the pace — and it’s easy to forget the person you’re teaching.

Scuba training is performance-based, and some students need more time to meet requirements. One trick that actually buys back time and helps progression is sometimes doing nothing at all. If a student is struggling with a skill, like mask clearing, instead of repeating it over and over, switch gears completely. Swim around, explore, blow bubbles, or find a crab or fish. It’s fun, relaxing, and exciting — exactly why they took the course. Once they’re relaxed, they’re much more receptive to learning.

Mistake #3 – Overthinking Presentations

Many candidates overprepare and try to appear perfect in front of assessors. Ironically, this can make presentations stiff or robotic. The candidates who succeed focus on clear explanations rather than perfection.

The IDC is a pressure cooker. You’re evaluated continually and receive feedback throughout. If an actual student asks a question during a dive course, you don’t stop to prepare a perfect presentation — you just answer and help them understand. That’s what we’re looking for in the IDC too: teaching students about diving in a clear, approachable way.

The PADI system is a fully stocked toolbox. We want candidates to know how to use the tools, even if not every tool is used in every session. Focus on delivering presentations as if your students were real — that’s enough. Full pages of notes to answer one question isn’t realistic; just explain the skill or knowledge clearly, simply, and effectively. Don’t forget to tell them how they will use it with you on their course dives.

Mistake #4 – Poor Buoyancy During Skill Demonstrations

Skill demonstrations are the core of instructor performance. Candidates with unstable buoyancy or poor body control can make even simple skills confusing or unsafe. Good buoyancy demonstrates confidence and control, allowing students to mirror correct technique.

There was a time when students performed all skills while kneeling on the bottom. I call this the “Planted Pot” technique. Many divemasters still come to the IDC with that old-school mindset. Now, we want students to learn real-world, applicable skills, starting with neutral buoyancy. Even a gentle fin pivot is better than being anchored to the bottom.

Remember, students emulate everything you do, so demonstrate skills correctly from the start. First impressions matter.

Mistake #5 – Talking Too Much During Briefings

Briefings should be structured, concise, and memorable. Too much information makes it harder for students to retain key points. It’s a briefing, not a longing.

Less is More: Start with the PADI Performance Requirement, explain why it’s important, outline the steps, note any hand signals, and organize the practice. Then get them underwater — that’s where learning happens. Spend more time doing than talking.

Mistake #6 – Worrying Too Much About the IE

Many candidates focus on the Instructor Examination before fully engaging in the IDC. Stressing about exams can actually hinder performance. Focus on learning first and confidence will follow.

Think of it like the phrase, “Are we there yet?” from a long car journey. Worrying doesn’t make the journey any faster. The IDC is designed to make you a competent instructor; the IE is just the checkpoint. By the time you reach it, you’re ready.

Mistake #7 – Forgetting That Teaching Is a Skill

Being a good diver doesn’t automatically make you a good instructor. Teaching is a skill that must be developed through practice, feedback, and reflection.

The PADI framework is a great place to start — Instructor Manual, Guide to Teaching, and student materials help organize lessons. But the bulk of your time in the IDC is spent learning how to teach. You might be a natural diver, but mastering the art of teaching takes practice.

Mistake #8 – Not Accepting Feedback Quickly Enough

Candidates receive a lot of feedback during the IDC. Those who embrace it immediately improve faster than those who resist.

Feedback isn’t meant to knock you down — it’s meant to help you improve. The sooner you apply it, the easier the IDC becomes, and the stronger an instructor you emerge as.

Mistake #9 – Not Realizing How Much They Improve

Many candidates underestimate their own growth. Skills that felt challenging at first become second nature by the end of the IDC. Recognizing this boosts confidence for the IE and for teaching future students.

The person who walks in on day one is not the same as the one who walks into the IE. You’ve learned, adapted, and improved tremendously — sometimes faster than you realize.

Conclusion / Takeaway

Mistakes are natural. What matters is recognizing them, being coachable, and applying feedback to improve. By understanding these common pitfalls, IDC candidates can grow faster, build confidence, and become instructors who inspire their students.

It’s not just about passing the IE — enjoy the process, have fun, and celebrate the growth.

Great instructors aren’t perfect divers — they’re learners, teachers, and guides who care enough to get it right every time.

Dive Promo!

10% off

Get 10% off your accommodation and free Nitrox tanks with a minimum pre-paid package of 3 nights & 6 dives

*Direct Bookings Only
**Booking period August 15th - December 1st, 2026